Armenian Authorities Remain Silent

Investigation

Even though five Armenian citizens died in the November plane crash in the Congo, the Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the General Department of Civil Aviation (GDCA) have offered only sketchy answers and no written reports about what happened. Officials refused to be interviewed and did not respond to Hetq.am questions.

Banner: OCCRP

November 18th, 2013

Armenia did not send investigators to the crash site and neither did experts from the Ilyushin Design Bureau, which designed the aircraft. From Russia, Ilyushin filed a preliminary report which notes poor weather conditions but lists no potential cause for the crash.

Shahen Petrosyan, head of the General Department of Civil Aviation of Armenia from 1993 to 1996, said Armenian representatives go to crash sites only in relatively non-serious cases. According to Petrosyan, when there are victims and potential criminal charges, the Interstate Aviation Committee (IAC), an organization made up of experts from Armenia and other former Soviet Union countries who now belong to the Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), travel to the crash site and investigate. But if the plane was no longer considered an Armenian-registered aircraft, the IAC would have no mandate to investigate. The IAC has not investigated or commented on the crash.

Registered in Armenia, They Operate Overseas

Eleven companies are registered with the General Department of Civil Aviation (GDCA). They are:

Many of these operate overseas, mostly in Africa and the United Arab Emirates. In 2009, Ishkhan Zakaryan, President of the Armenia Control Chamber, whose responsibility is to independently investigate government activity, said that both Armenian and foreign airline companies register in Armenia since it is free. In addition, Zakraryan said companies registered in Armenia but operating overseas pay low taxes to the Armenian government. According to figures from the Armenia State Revenue Committee, the only Armenia-based airline that made it onto the 2012 list of the 1,000 top taxpayers was Armavia, which came in 326th after paying $286 million in taxes.

Armenia-Based Airplanes Change Registration

As of January 2012, the UAE had prohibited planes bearing the EK (Armenian) national brand to land except for passenger airplanes Armavia operated. Armenia-based planes can only pass through UAE air space. Pilot Armen Mnatsakanyan says that this same UAE ban applies to Kazakh, Moldovan and Tajik planes. As of March 2012, 18 planes with EK coding appeared on http://talks.milkavkaz.net, a forum that discusses aviation topics. The information displayed on the forum was taken from Ilyushin official website. One year later, that number dropped to eight. When it became known that the UAE had banned Armenian planes, aviation-related forums were abuzz with talk that many airplanes would be registered in other countries in the near future. This seems to have happened.

The table below shows the registration changes that have been made since March 2012.

Former Arm. Number

Former Arm. Owner

Current Number

Current Owner

EK-76425

Reliable Unique Services Aviation

YI-AQX

Al-Naser Airlines (Iraq)

EK-76485

Reliable Unique Services Aviation

EY-701

Khatlon Air (Tajikistan

EK-76111

Reliable Unique Services Aviation

ER-IAW

Aerotrans Cargo (Moldova)

EK-76808

Reliable Unique Services Aviation

EY-608

Par Air (Tajikistan)

EK-76464

Phoenix Avia

EY-609

Par Air (Tajikistan)

EK-76787

Phoenix Avia

RA-76416

Kosmos Airlines (Russia)

EK-76643

Taron-Avia

EY-703

Khatlon Air (Tajikistan)

EK-76603

Ark Airways

ER-IBZ

Aerotrans Cargo (Moldova

EK-76812

Veteran Avia

ER-IAL

ER-IAL Jet Star (Moldova)

EK-76401

Veteran Avia

ER-IAL

ER-IAK Jet Star (Moldova)

RUS Aviation and Phoenix Avia are based in the UAE city of Sharjah. The same holds true for Skiva Air and South Airlines, companies with Armenian operating licenses.

Foreigners Also Own Airline Companies

Below is information from the State Registry on companies licensed to operate airplanes in Armenia. Airline companies periodically operate, shut down or reorganize.

Name

Year Founded

Stockholders

Shares

Executive Body director

Atlantis European Airways LLC

1999

Atlantis Group Ltd,
Saturn Reisebureau Ltd (Austria)

90 %,
10 %

Rolland Margaryan

Ark Airways LLC

2009

Robert Baghdasaryan,
Yevgeny Lavretski (Russia)

51 %,
49 %

Robert Baghdasaryan

Air Armenia CJSC

2003

Ruzanna Tovmasyan,
Vahan Harutyunyan

50 %,
50 %

Arsen Avetisyan

Armenia Airways Air Company CJSC

2013

Main Aviation Technics,
Armen Sargsyan

50 %,
50 %

Karen Movsisyan

Ayk Avia Air Company CJSC

2002

Shahen Aghababyan,
Armen Vantsyan

50 %,
50 %

Haykanoush Mkhitaryan

Reliable Unique Services Aviation LLC

2009

Hrachya Hovhannisyan,
Sergey Astionov (Kyrgyzstan)

51 %,
49 %

Anoush Margaryan

South Airlines LLC

2000

Zanik Simonyan,
Danuteh Simonyan,
Karineh Simonyan

42 %,
29 %,
29%

Samvel Harutyunyan

Skiva Air LLC

2011

Lusineh Khachatryan,
Vahram Simonyan

51 %,
49 %

Samvel Harutyunyan

Sky Net Airline LLC

2011

National Aviation Coalition, NGO

100 %

Grigori Vardanyan

Veteran Avia LLC

2010

Sona Gevorgyan,
Bilal Malik (Russia),
Amir Mouhammad (Russia)

52 %,
24 %,
24 %

Artashes Gevorgyan

Taron-Avia LLC

2007

Garnik Papikyan

100 %

Garnik Papikyan